Vinous - Score: 98 (2018 February)

The 1959 Palmer is a Margaux of renown, albeit one eclipsed by the peerless 1961. This bottle testified the awe that it has invoked in some of my friends, the best bottle that I have tasted. The first word that I jotted down? “Wow”. The aromatics soar from the glass with intense blackberry, cassis, juniper berry and violets that brilliantly defined and display astonishing focus. The palate is perfectly balanced with sweet and filigree tannin. This Margaux is that paradoxical blend of power and elegance, the archetypal iron fist in a velvety glove. The purity of the wine remarkable. Yes, maybe you could quibble that there is a touch of volatility on the finish that would not be evident on the 1961 but otherwise, this is a majestic Palmer that judging by this performance, will continue to drink well for many years.